Discussion:
Grandmother's recipe
(too old to reply)
Malcolm Loades
2021-12-30 13:15:34 UTC
Permalink
Interesting article about mother/grandmother recipes in The Guardian
today https://tinyurl.com/y6ou9rgm

Unless they were written down by mother/grandmother and that ancient
written copy kept and followed to the letter each time I thinks it's
almost guaranteed to have evolved into a different dish.

I'd been making Chilli con Carne from Delia Smith's Complete Cookery
Course since it was first published 40 years ago. I knew the recipe so
well that it's decades since I last looked at the recipe in the book.

Then a couple of years ago I was running late so called my wife and
asked her to make the chilli for which the ingredients were already in
the house. When she asked how I said just follow the recipe in Delia's
Complete Cookery Course.

It was completely different to the Chilli con Carne I make! Over the
years my making of Delia's chilli had ever so slowly evolved into my
Chilli con Carne and was no longer Delia's recipe.

Malcolm
Graham
2021-12-30 15:59:13 UTC
Permalink
Post by Malcolm Loades
Interesting article about mother/grandmother recipes in The Guardian
today https://tinyurl.com/y6ou9rgm
Unless they were written down by mother/grandmother and that ancient
written copy kept and followed to the letter each time I thinks it's
almost guaranteed to have evolved into a different dish.
I'd been making Chilli con Carne from Delia Smith's Complete Cookery
Course since it was first published 40 years ago.  I knew the recipe so
well that it's decades since I last looked at the recipe in the book.
Then a couple of years ago I was running late so called my wife and
asked her to make the chilli for which the ingredients were already in
the house.  When she asked how I said just follow the recipe in Delia's
Complete Cookery Course.
It was completely different to the Chilli con Carne I make!  Over the
years my making of Delia's chilli had ever so slowly evolved into my
Chilli con Carne and was no longer Delia's recipe.
Malcolm
I'm sure the almond tarts that I make at xmas, instead of mince pies,
are different from those my mother made. They were certainly a bit
different this year as there was a power failure while I was baking and
my oven's temperature was off. Never buy a Bosch oven!!!!!!

Incidentally, I have an old exercise book with at least 3 generations of
recipes, the earliest written in the most beautiful copperplate hand,
that was started by my ex's great-great grandmother. There are recipes
for brewing beer (and restoring stale beer) mushroom ketchup and many
cakes, but the latter require knowledge of baking with a coal-fired
oven. There are also home remedies and instructions for making stove
blacking.
Judith in France
2022-01-04 12:19:34 UTC
Permalink
Post by Graham
Post by Malcolm Loades
Interesting article about mother/grandmother recipes in The Guardian
today https://tinyurl.com/y6ou9rgm
Unless they were written down by mother/grandmother and that ancient
written copy kept and followed to the letter each time I thinks it's
almost guaranteed to have evolved into a different dish.
I'd been making Chilli con Carne from Delia Smith's Complete Cookery
Course since it was first published 40 years ago. I knew the recipe so
well that it's decades since I last looked at the recipe in the book.
Then a couple of years ago I was running late so called my wife and
asked her to make the chilli for which the ingredients were already in
the house. When she asked how I said just follow the recipe in Delia's
Complete Cookery Course.
It was completely different to the Chilli con Carne I make! Over the
years my making of Delia's chilli had ever so slowly evolved into my
Chilli con Carne and was no longer Delia's recipe.
Malcolm
I'm sure the almond tarts that I make at xmas, instead of mince pies,
are different from those my mother made. They were certainly a bit
different this year as there was a power failure while I was baking and
my oven's temperature was off. Never buy a Bosch oven!!!!!!
Incidentally, I have an old exercise book with at least 3 generations of
recipes, the earliest written in the most beautiful copperplate hand,
that was started by my ex's great-great grandmother. There are recipes
for brewing beer (and restoring stale beer) mushroom ketchup and many
cakes, but the latter require knowledge of baking with a coal-fired
oven. There are also home remedies and instructions for making stove
blacking.
When I moved to France I had to get used to cooking on a log fuelled Aga type cooker, oh my I dished up many odd meals, one needs a degree in engineering to use one of these.
Judith in France
2022-01-04 12:18:16 UTC
Permalink
Post by Malcolm Loades
Interesting article about mother/grandmother recipes in The Guardian
today https://tinyurl.com/y6ou9rgm
Unless they were written down by mother/grandmother and that ancient
written copy kept and followed to the letter each time I thinks it's
almost guaranteed to have evolved into a different dish.
I'd been making Chilli con Carne from Delia Smith's Complete Cookery
Course since it was first published 40 years ago. I knew the recipe so
well that it's decades since I last looked at the recipe in the book.
Then a couple of years ago I was running late so called my wife and
asked her to make the chilli for which the ingredients were already in
the house. When she asked how I said just follow the recipe in Delia's
Complete Cookery Course.
It was completely different to the Chilli con Carne I make! Over the
years my making of Delia's chilli had ever so slowly evolved into my
Chilli con Carne and was no longer Delia's recipe.
Malcolm
Isn't that what happens to all recipes, my Christmas pud recipe comes originally from the same book Delia's complete cookery course. However, said pud now has more grated apple and acrrot and a load more brandy in it!!!
Judith in France
2022-01-09 11:13:58 UTC
Permalink
Post by Malcolm Loades
Interesting article about mother/grandmother recipes in The Guardian
today https://tinyurl.com/y6ou9rgm
Unless they were written down by mother/grandmother and that ancient
written copy kept and followed to the letter each time I thinks it's
almost guaranteed to have evolved into a different dish.
I'd been making Chilli con Carne from Delia Smith's Complete Cookery
Course since it was first published 40 years ago. I knew the recipe so
well that it's decades since I last looked at the recipe in the book.
Then a couple of years ago I was running late so called my wife and
asked her to make the chilli for which the ingredients were already in
the house. When she asked how I said just follow the recipe in Delia's
Complete Cookery Course.
It was completely different to the Chilli con Carne I make! Over the
years my making of Delia's chilli had ever so slowly evolved into my
Chilli con Carne and was no longer Delia's recipe.
Malcolm
Isn't that what happens to all recipes, my Christmas pud recipe comes originally from the same book Delia's complete cookery course. However, said pud now has more grated apple and acrrot and a load more brandy in it!!!
I no longer make xmas pud or cakes but when I did, I always soaked the
fruit in sherry overnight. I used a hypodermic to inject the cakes with
Grand Marnier or Cointreau during the maturing period:-)
I don't make a cake a good friend does and she injects it also. Puds I do make in October and I make an extra one to eat next year! I pour over a good glug of cognac before sealing for the year.
Loading...